The Heart Exchange
September 24, 2010 by Bob Regnerus
My definition of a true friend: When you can unload a pile of garbage in front of them and they climb over the heap to get to you instead of focusing on, cleaning up, or trying to organize the mess.
I’ve come to the conclusion that I prefer friends that are really screwed up. Not because it makes me look better, but because I know it’s authentic. Now if you are one of my friends don’t think I’m saying you’re screwed up in a bad way. I am saying that in you, I see a genuine person with a good heart that is trying to navigate the pressures of life best you can and doesn’t always get it right. That we don’t need to put on a good face in front of each other and appear to be altogether. That we can unload garbage and not try to clean it up. That we don’t fear being judged for our emotions, actions, or words.
I want friends where I can pour all my garbage on the table and not have them try to put it into neat piles. I want that friend to climb over the mountains of crap to get to me and bear with me through the mess. I want to be that friend for other people.
Sitting with friends last night, we each had a chance to pour stuff from our hearts. Stuff that we’ve been dealing with together for a while. I love that we get to honestly share messes with people we sincerely love, and not have one urge to try and fix anything or expect them to so the same.
3 years ago as Matt was going through some major stuff, I remember being naive enough to think I had the power (and the right) to provide him answers. I’d listen to his issues, ponder them, and begin to prescribe solutions. What an arrogant ass I was! No wonder he kept telling me, “I don’t need you to fix this, I just need to vent”.
I know people are being sincere when they offer up their words of encouragement or start to try and fix things. I’m pretty sure they feel like they have to respond, so it sounds really holy to say, “We’re praying for you.” It’s almost like we’re saying, “Wow, that’s messed up. I’m not really sure I want to get involved with that.” (Now seriously, when you’ve ever said that to someone, do you really? Ok, so as you offer your response, you go, “God, please be with Bob”. Then you go about your day. Mostly, we don’t ever even pray that lazy prayer.)
I’ve just learned that it’s not cool to provide solutions, rote prayers, or quote random scripture to a friend. These “answers” or responses have not been earned, and they are cheap bandaids that fall off in 5 minutes.
I’ve learned that there’s a cost to be able to sit in front of someone and walk through their garbage pile. That cost is your heart.
I don’t believe until you exchange hearts with someone, you will ever get the right to stand in their garbage pile, or look them in the eye and tell them they are full of crap or wrong, or seriously celebrate a breakthrough and share the joy. The currency of humankind is hearts. Until you exchange your heart with someone else’s, you don’t have an authentic relationship.
If you know me, you know I have been building an authentic relationship with Father. I just realized something. In order to have an authentic relationship with me, he had to give me his heart, because until I got his heart, I could never trust him with mine. Contrary to popular belief, I did not choose to give my heart to him first. God chose to give me his heart first, and then I saw it was safe to give mine to him. This life is about releasing your heart to him, and then doing that for those around you.
So with Arlene, with my girls, with Matt, and a few good friends – we’ve invested in each other. We’ve exchanged hearts. We can choose to value this investment or not. It’s risky to hand over your heart to someone because it might not get taken care of, but you haven’t lived until you’ve exchanged hearts with someone and taken that risk.
I’m so glad that in this past year, and very much so in the last couple weeks, I’ve had the pleasure of sitting around piles of garbage with people I’ve exchanged hearts with. I enjoy the authenticity of the relationships and the lack of pressure to solve every problem. I want to do this more, and I hope the new path we’e stepping onto allows this to happen even more.

Love it, Bob! Reminds me of the Casting Crowns song “Stained Glass Masquerade”:
So I tuck it all away, like everything’s okay
If I make them all believe it, maybe I’ll believe it too
So with a painted grin, I play the part again
So everyone will see me the way that I see them
Are we happy plastic people
Under shiny plastic steeples
With walls around our weakness
And smiles to hide our pain
(Complete lyrics at
http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/castingcrowns/stainedglassmasquerade.html)
I don’t know that we can ever fully touch God if we can never fully touch another person with complete trust and openness. There’s so much of Jesus that He’s put in other people, and that I will miss if I don’t reach out.
I’m just beginning on this journey myself – 30+ years into salvation!! But it’s wonderful to finally have real friends I don’t have to be afraid of – they won’t reject me just because I throw out my problem in front of them.
I think that’s the “one body” concept – sure glad my leg didn’t cast off my foot when it had an ingrown toenail! Even though the whole body seemed to hurt.
Ed
[...] To Exchange Your Heart? Bob Regnerus brings up some good points in his article, “The Heart Exchange“, when he considers what a true friend is, how we should become one and why. The point I [...]
You’ve probably long since noted the implication of Ephesians 3:9 that we’re all on stage, as we work through our garbage piles toward the Superbowl rings Jesus promises us in Revelation Chapters 2 and 3 … with the stage in full vew of people, angels, and the demonic hosts of Ephesians 6:12.
Using the identical plot of Job chapters 1 and 2, Bill Myers wrote his book WAGER to illustrate how God still has His cosmic bets with the devil. In WAGER God bets on a Christian actor, who is about to win an Academy Award, that in spite of every test the devil can throw at him, he can faithfully comply with every command of Jesus in Matthew chapters 5 through 7 (The Sermon on the Amount.) …
… even as he finds himself hopelessly incapable of doing so at almost every point.
The Lord teaches us white and black, then sends us out to navigate the garbage piles of a world composed of ten thousand shades of gray …
… where the tests in this round ready us for the ten-times-tougher tests we’ll need to help our friends through the next round.
As we answer the bell for the next round, don’t leave Him in your corner. Remember He is in you to accomplish the overcoming through which He gets all the Glory …
Sermon on the “Amount” ??? Where did that come from? Maybe, accidentally, He’s reminding of the incredible Amount of resources He’s made available to accomplish the Overcoming …